NSW assisted dying bill defeated by one vote, but we are not defeated
The NSW Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill was a private member’s bill introduced by Nationals MP Trevor Khan, a member of the Parliamentary Working Group on Assisted Dying. The bill, which they had developed over two years, in consultation with key stakeholders, failed to pass in the NSW Upper House by one vote. All MPs were given a conscience vote (apart from the 5 Greens who supported it as party policy and the 2 Christian Democrats who opposed it as the policy of their party). The final vote, taken at 11.15 pm on Thursday 16 November 2017, was 19 votes in favour, 20 opposed.
The morning of the 16 November started off well, with a great gathering of members and supporters wearing blue DWD T-shirts, and holding placards in front of Parliament House. There was lots of media present, and issue of voluntary assisted dying and the imminent debate received lots of coverage on TV, radio, print and digital media.
NSW UPPER HOUSE VOLUNTARY ASSISTED DYING BILL
How They Voted on 16 November 2017 – Breakdown by Party
Trevor Khan MLC vowed in his speech in Parliament just prior to the final vote, not to walk away from the issue, but to reintroduce a voluntary assisted dying bill in the next term of Parliament (after the 2019 state election).
The NSW Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill was prepared over the past two years by the NSW Parliamentary Working Group on Assisted Dying, consisting of:
- Trevor Khan MLC (Nationals)
- Dr. Mehreen Faruqi MLC (Greens)
- Lynda Voltz MLC (Labor)
- Lee Evans MLA (Liberal)
- Alex Greenwich MLA (Independent)
The board and members of Dying with Dignity NSW would like to thank the members of the Parliamentary Working Group on Assisted Dying and all those Members of the NSW Legislative Council who voted in support of the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill (2017)
Click for ABC News article 17 November 2017 ‘Euthanasia: Assisted dying advocates ‘heartbroken’ over bill’s failure in NSW Parliament’
According to Sarah Edelman, President of DWD NSW, in the Sydney Morning Herald article 17 November 2017 ‘Religious groups doomed Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill‘
“….more than half of the 20 MPs who opposed the bill made reference to their religious faith, “sanctity of life” and teachings of Christ. What then followed were all the classic references to “unintended consequences”, “crossing the Rubicon”, harm to the vulnerable, and damage to the mental health of participating doctors. Cases from overseas countries that have legalised assisted dying were cited with facts deliberately distorted, and the laws in Belgian and Netherlands were confounded with the much more conservative Oregon model, on which the NSW bill was based.”
Significantly, the leader of the Christian Democratic Party, Reverend Fred Nile, admitted the following day to Fairfax Media that he had “made a mistake” and that the horror case from Oregon that he had referred to in his parliamentary speech had actually occurred under the much more liberal euthanasia laws that operate in the Netherlands, rather than in Oregon, upon which the NSW Bill is based. For more details see the Sydney Morning Herald article 17 November 2017 ‘ ‘God prompted me’: Fred Nile’s error in horror story during NSW assisted dying debate‘
Shayne Higson, Vice President of DWD NSW, (pictured above prior to the debate in parliament early on the morning of 16 November) gave Ute Schulenberg of Guardian News feedback about the events of the 16 November 2017.
Shayne commended the nineteen members of the Upper House who supported the Bill, especially the five National Party MPs who voted ‘yes’, saying “We are very proud of National Party members in both houses because they have really looked at the evidence and listened to the people … some of them having changed their previously held views.”
However, Shayne confessed that “We really thought we had the numbers … we had worked so hard and met with so many members of Parliament but a couple of Coalition MP’s changed their position at the last minute,..It’s really hard – it won’t be back before the NSW Parliament before late 2019, at the earliest. We have to wait until after the next election, which is in March 2019. It’s a long wait, and for people like me, who are so close to the issue, I can’t help thinking about the hundreds of people who will die badly because this Bill failed to pass.”
See Guardian News article 20 November 2017 ‘No relief for the terminally-ill’
Click to download Hansard as a pdf (87 pages) Hansard VOLUNTARY ASSISTED DYING BILL 2017 NSW 16 November 2017
For more information about the NSW Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill (2017) see our website post 21 September 2017 ‘NSW Bill presented in Parliament‘